Tuesday, November 20, 1990 (Landing Day) – Guess who’s coming for dinner“It’s great to have her home, and right here where she left. It’s a sight more rare than a launch here.” - Forrest S. McCartney, Kennedy Space Center Director
COMIN’ IN TO KSC
The astronauts never did like landing the shuttle at the moat-lined confines of the Shuttle Landing facility at the Kennedy Space Center. “At this point, I’m not willing to commit as to when we’ll start planning Kennedy landings,” Robert Crippen, head of the shuttle program and former astronaut, had said following the STS-41 mission in October. He would say no more than that he would “evaluate” the question next summer.
Suddenly, late on November 19, the words Kennedy and landing were being combined more forcefully – like a strong wind. The desert winds of that day had caused Atlantis STS-38 to miss two landing opportunities at Edwards Air Force Base, California. The Edwards forecast for November 20 did not portend well for a California landing. Atlantis, completing the last “secret” DOD flight, possessed ample supplies to orbit for two days beyond the 20th, yet suddenly flight controllers were mentioning KSC landing much more than for any flight since Challenger.
“We have alerted the KSC landing and recovery forces to the possibility that they may be a landing site selection tomorrow,” said Randy Stone, chief of the Flight Directors Office at the Johnson Space Center, in a rare press conference during a DOD mission. “Our normal strategy for picking a runway after a waive-off day is if we have consumables plus two (supplies for two days more in orbit), we will continue to try our primary landing site, which is Edwards,” he said, but KSC kept creeping back in his press briefing. “We have not done anything to preclude being able to land at KSC from the standpoint of support.”
The decision would have to come well before landing. The deorbit burn for the first of three landing opportunities to Edwards would come on orbit 79 at 2:30 p.m. CST. The only KSC opportunity for the day would come on the same orbit, with the start of the deorbit burn coming just eight minutes after the Edwards time. “So we would have to make the decision between the runways early enough to do our normal deorbit targeting and preparation,” Stone said. The decision would come after a look at the weather forecast in the morning. While KSC, as the backup landing site, stood ready on two hour’s notice for a landing, the decision probably would come sooner than that.
The last KSC landing had been made by Discovery on Mission 16, STS 51-D, on April 19, 1985, landing in a crosswind that had to be countered by heavy braking. The brakes locked, and the tire blew out – luckily at the end of the rollout and not at the start, when it could have been disastrous.
Since that time, nose wheel steering has been upgraded as a replacement by the steering-by-brake-force used previously. The shuttle’s beryllium brakes are being replaced by improved all-carbon ones – however, Atlantis was still equipped with the old brakes. The SLF runway, grooved as a rain precaution, was smoothed along 3,500 feet at each end, since the rain grooves tore at the tires.
NASA had maintained that a return to KSC awaited obtaining more data on crosswind landings, more brake tests, and other improvements, such as the drag parachutes now being developed. The main restraint to KSC landings, however, lay in weather forecasting, which needed improvement. The Florida weather along the Atlantic coast can change quickly, with rapid formation of fog or thunderstorms. The shuttle becomes committed to a landing at the time of the deorbit burn one hour prior to touchdown – time enough for the finicky Florida Weather to shift.
TO BOLDLY GO WHERE FEW SHUTTLES HAVE GONE
On the morning of November 20, winds remained above landing limits at Edwards, with the same forecasted for the next day. Weather at Kennedy was holding clear – and more importantly, stable… at least for the day. Slightly worsening conditions were forecasted for the 21st. Therefore, the decision was made to take the best weather on the best day.
At about 11:00 a.m. CST, NASA made the announcement: “We have selected Kennedy Space Center Shuttle Landing Facility as the primary landing site for today… With the uncertainty of tomorrow’s forecast, the flight control team has opted to designate the SLF as our primary site…”
“We had been ready for it, and quite frankly, we did not make any different preparations,” KSC Director Forrest McCartney said.
Activities progressed smoothly towards the deorbit burn at 2:38 p.m. CST – and the closely watched weather mirrored the preparations aboard Atlantis by Dick Covey and crew. Reporting 21 minutes before the burn, Mission Control said, “Winds are still very stable, predicted to be well within headwind and crosswind peak limitations.”
At about 2:30 p.m. CST, the shuttle passed out of communications range for five minutes over the Indian Ocean. During that period, the crew was to start one of the Auxiliary Power Units, which drive the hydraulic system. At the same time, the landing convoy of servicing trucks began to move into position at the SLF runway – 1 hour 7 minutes to landing…
PAO:
This is Mission Control Houston. We’ve reacquired signal through the western satellite. Flight controllers here in Houston now watching live telemetry as we’ve locked onto the vehicle’s signal. Indications are that Auxiliary Power Unit #1 has been started and prestart for #2 and #3 underway… Air-to-ground circuits very quiet. Flight controllers here happy to leave the crew alone to complete their tasks leading up to the deorbit burn. The one minute 53 second burn began and Mission Control reported, “Guidance officer reports that control looks very good… Telemetry confirms that the burn is complete, and the vehicle is now being maneuvered to the entry interface attitude.” Entry interface, the point where the shuttle first encountered the atmosphere, was twenty minutes away. Atlantis now was committed to a Florida Landing, come hell, high water – or high wind.
The final two APUs were started. At 4:04 p.m. EST, the landing convoy reported they were in position at the middle of the SLF. Overhead, the Shuttle Training Aircraft, piloted by Astronaut Mike Coats, was making weather passes. “Weather conditions at the landing site remain unchanged. All systems performing well.”
At 4:06 p.m. EST, the shuttle’s computers switched to “Major Mode 304,” the program for atmospheric flight. Five minutes later, entry interface occurred. “Atlantis and crew now beginning to first experience the effects of the upper reaches of the atmosphere; onboard systems now show Atlantis at 360,000 feet, traveling at Mach 24, descending into the atmosphere at 500 feet per second; range to the landing site right now 3,800 nautical miles.”
Atlantis crossed 292,000 feet over the southern tip of the Baja California peninsula, beginning her track across Mexico while at Mach 24.4, descending at 440 feet per second. 3,100 miles from the SLF runway, Atlantis began a series of S-turns to bleed off speed, starting with a 73-degree right bank… Altitude 252,000 feet, speed Mach 24, descent rate 93 feet per second. At Mach 20.8, Atlantis performed a roll reversal, snaking from right to a 73-degree left bank… Range 1,500 to KSC, altitude 2227,000 feet, descent rate 125 feet per second.
PAO:
Crew Commander Dick Covey radioing that they’re crossing the South Texas coast out over the Gulf of Mexico at about South Padre Island, saying that it looked like a beautiful day down there. Atlantis now tracking east/northeast across the Gulf of Mexico…As Atlantis neared the Florida peninsula, CapCom Ken Bowersox radioed that energy, ground track, and navigation were go – meaning Atlantis was plotting a perfect course for her Florida home. Less than nine minutes to landing, Atlantis reached the Florida coast just south of Crystal River – at an altitude of 115,000 feet. The first long-range cameras from KSC caught sight of the orbiter – a hazy white needle as it descended at 300 feet per second. The needle grew slowly in the murky long-range eye until it crystallized as a side view of the orbiter making a 30-degree right bank.
PAO:
Now taking our first long-range views of Atlantis as it approaches the terminal area… This view captured from a range nearly clear across the Florida peninsula; range now 98 nautical miles, altitude 103,000 feet, velocity Mach 3.7, descending at 300 feet per second… Crew aboard Atlantis given a go to take air data now to guidance and control; that information in the form of barometric, or atmospheric changes helps reinforce onboard guidance and navigation as well as cockpit displays with regard to altitude and airspeed… Atlantis continuing in a right bank of about 30 degrees; range now 54 nautical miles, altitude 81,000 feet… Crew given a go to incorporate air data into the onboard navigation systems; Atlantis now under the guidance of Terminal Area Energy Management software; onboard guidance now steering Atlantis to Way Point One, the point at which the vehicle will first begin turning around the Heading Alignment Cone to properly align the vehicle for final approach and landing; range now 38 nautical miles, altitude 69,000 feet; Atlantis traveling at Mach 1.5, descending at 320 feet per second… Atlantis has cleared its cross over Orlando, now beginning to approach subsonic speeds – dual sonic booms anticipated as Atlantis arrives just east of Titusville on its track over the Indian River at about 4:38 Eastern Standard Time in just a couple of seconds… Range 30 nautical miles, altitude 57,000 feet… Atlantis now wings level, reaching for the way Point One…