NASASpaceFlight.com Forum

SpaceX Vehicles and Missions => SpaceX Facilities and Fleets => Topic started by: Helodriver on 05/03/2016 08:07 pm

Title: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Helodriver on 05/03/2016 08:07 pm
OCISLY is at once more at sea trying to get a winning streak going and not a greasy streak burned across the deck! Its possibly going to be another "suicide slam" so how it goes is anyone's guess.

The game remains exactly as played for CRS-8 ( http://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=39977.0 )

Pick your square, one per player. Closest square to the center engine when it comes to a halt gets the prize! 

No prize for fireballs, debris, or damage on deck!

If it hits the ship, goes kaboom, punctures holes in the deck, falls over in transit, or splashes down in the sea, there is no winner. Only a booster standing tall and triumphant as the ASDS sails into the harbor will generate a win! It worked last time so no need to incentivize failure ;)

Water squares are meaningless, if falls in the sea, no winners - no prize. Feel free to pick a water square just for "I told you so" bragging rights if you wish! ;)

This thread remains the official record of who chose what square when. For that reason any edited pick post is invalid.

Use Dan's scraper to see which spots have gone:

http://asds.dansdoorway.com

Judging is by me, I expect there will be many photographs of OCISLY sailing back into the harbor to help determine a winner.

Good luck SpaceX, Good luck JCSAT, and Good luck to NSF readers!

ONE YEAR FREE L2 MEMBERSHIP TO THE LUCKY WINNER

And a piece of SpaceX swag from me!

(Prior winners I've not still have not forgotten your stuff, I'm still going to get you some authentic SpaceX Historical Artifacts, not mere swag!)  :)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: ClayJar on 05/03/2016 08:08 pm
L21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DatUser14 on 05/03/2016 08:09 pm
L20
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Tuts36 on 05/03/2016 08:09 pm
I-20 pls!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Paul_G on 05/03/2016 08:10 pm
 J25 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Poole Amateur on 05/03/2016 08:10 pm
K21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lar on 05/03/2016 08:10 pm
M21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: sevenperforce on 05/03/2016 08:10 pm
E26
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Doesitfloat on 05/03/2016 08:13 pm
j24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: nadreck on 05/03/2016 08:13 pm
K9
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Kabloona on 05/03/2016 08:15 pm
K-22
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: ClayJar on 05/03/2016 08:15 pm
Okay, now that I got to hit the center, I suppose I'm committed to hoping for unexpectedly calm seas and winds on landing so I don't miss by a scoot.  ;D

(Oh, who am I kidding.  I would be fantastically delighted to be off by two squares again and get to watch another triumphant return to port.)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Rocket Science on 05/03/2016 08:16 pm
F23 please! :)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: acsawdey on 05/03/2016 08:17 pm
H24 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Retired Downrange on 05/03/2016 08:18 pm
M22 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: shooter6947 on 05/03/2016 08:19 pm
M19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Endeavour126 on 05/03/2016 08:19 pm
N27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mme on 05/03/2016 08:20 pm
O14
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Chris Bergin on 05/03/2016 08:20 pm
K20

Just save time and give me the L2 membership right now. Oh wait... ;)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lar on 05/03/2016 08:21 pm
Okay, now that I got to hit the center, I suppose I'm committed to hoping for unexpectedly calm seas and winds on landing so I don't miss by a scoot.  ;D

(Oh, who am I kidding.  I would be fantastically delighted to be off by two squares again and get to watch another triumphant return to port.)
Congrats on scoring a square so close to dead on!!!!

I am the closest to the center I've ever been either. And I'd be happy to miss by as many squares as necessary, as long as it stays on the ASDS...

I pinged Dan about resetting the scraper, which is still pointing to the old board as of this writing.

K20

Just save time and give me the L2 membership right now. Oh wait... ;)

watch it decide that your square is L2 rather than K 20 ....

Edit:  That scraper is a Fair Dinkum Thinkum ...

Chris Bergin has selected K-20
Square   Reference Post   Result
K-20    Today at 08:20 PM    Vote Counted
L-2     Today at 08:20 PM    User has previous choice
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: abaddon on 05/03/2016 08:23 pm
M-15 please and thank you!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DeanHFox on 05/03/2016 08:24 pm
R21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mrkmrsk on 05/03/2016 08:25 pm
P16
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Andy Smith on 05/03/2016 08:26 pm
J23 please


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Kalud on 05/03/2016 08:26 pm
K18
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: abneric on 05/03/2016 08:26 pm
O20


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: RollingOn on 05/03/2016 08:26 pm
E24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Rebel44 on 05/03/2016 08:26 pm
J18
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: wannamoonbase on 05/03/2016 08:27 pm
N13
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Flying Beaver on 05/03/2016 08:27 pm
M24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Zucal on 05/03/2016 08:28 pm
N-19, please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mattrog on 05/03/2016 08:28 pm
F24 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Sputnik on 05/03/2016 08:31 pm
N24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: leovinus on 05/03/2016 08:33 pm
N16
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Fractality on 05/03/2016 08:35 pm
K23
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: caudexsum on 05/03/2016 08:36 pm
F19 please if I haven't been beaten to it
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: bldrfritz on 05/03/2016 08:36 pm
Q26 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: pauldalyroi on 05/03/2016 08:36 pm
C27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: hapax.legomina on 05/03/2016 08:38 pm
L24 please!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: MaxFlint on 05/03/2016 08:38 pm
F15
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Toastmastern on 05/03/2016 08:40 pm
H-21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: TransAlpUK on 05/03/2016 08:42 pm
P-15 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: RedLineTrain on 05/03/2016 08:45 pm
K19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: TransAlpUK on 05/03/2016 08:45 pm
P-15 for me please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: kirghizstan on 05/03/2016 08:47 pm
p 16
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: cesarparent on 05/03/2016 08:47 pm
I'll take P-13 please :)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Gliderflyer on 05/03/2016 08:47 pm
G24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DanielW on 05/03/2016 08:48 pm
L-22 and the scraper is up. I never seem to be checking NSF when these things go up. Sorry.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Barrie on 05/03/2016 08:49 pm
O19 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: William Graham on 05/03/2016 08:49 pm
P17 please.

I almost mistyped P77. I hope that is not the case.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Jeff Lerner on 05/03/2016 08:50 pm
P21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: meberbs on 05/03/2016 08:52 pm
M23 for me please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: josecurioso on 05/03/2016 08:54 pm
L18
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: IntoTheVoid on 05/03/2016 08:54 pm
M20
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mheney on 05/03/2016 08:56 pm
H19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: fishbait on 05/03/2016 08:58 pm
P25 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Navier–Stokes on 05/03/2016 08:58 pm
G20
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: silverfire on 05/03/2016 08:59 pm
N23
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: cartman on 05/03/2016 09:00 pm
L-19
Title: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: jnaO on 05/03/2016 09:01 pm
P23
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: hygoex on 05/03/2016 09:09 pm
I-22
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Comga on 05/03/2016 09:09 pm
N-20
Gotta move fast!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: heweheweh on 05/03/2016 09:15 pm
J20, please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: whitelancer64 on 05/03/2016 09:25 pm
F 17
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: brudosm on 05/03/2016 09:26 pm
M17 please. Thank you.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: matthewkantar on 05/03/2016 09:27 pm
G 22 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: tleski on 05/03/2016 09:29 pm
N21 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: McDew on 05/03/2016 09:30 pm
C9
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Astrophil on 05/03/2016 09:31 pm
N22 please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Toast on 05/03/2016 09:38 pm
J21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Mayberry Chief on 05/03/2016 09:40 pm
0-23
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: BrakeFirst on 05/03/2016 09:42 pm
P18,
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: FutureSpaceTourist on 05/03/2016 09:45 pm
J19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Endeavour_01 on 05/03/2016 09:45 pm
J17 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: wenderro on 05/03/2016 09:46 pm
O-22
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mleigh on 05/03/2016 09:52 pm
M-18
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mshook on 05/03/2016 09:55 pm
K16 for me
Or is it
K-16
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: RDMM2081 on 05/03/2016 09:55 pm
H26 please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: FishInferno on 05/03/2016 10:03 pm
I-21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Babbaloo on 05/03/2016 10:06 pm
H-17 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Blizzzard on 05/03/2016 10:06 pm
N-18
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Meltro on 05/03/2016 10:10 pm
O-23
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: skyguy on 05/03/2016 10:16 pm
L-23, please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: hpras on 05/03/2016 10:17 pm
K-26 Please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Baranquilla on 05/03/2016 10:23 pm
J-22, please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Jakusb on 05/03/2016 10:28 pm
O-21 please


Verzonden vanaf mijn iPad met Tapatalk
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Ohsin on 05/03/2016 10:39 pm
L17
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Jdeshetler on 05/03/2016 10:40 pm
O-17
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: ZachS09 on 05/03/2016 10:46 pm
I will go for L-12 this time.

Go Falcon. Go JCSat 14.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: dorkmo on 05/03/2016 10:49 pm
O-18
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: enzo on 05/03/2016 10:53 pm
K-24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Silmfeanor on 05/03/2016 10:57 pm
I-16 please!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: stope19 on 05/03/2016 10:59 pm
O-23
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: schaban on 05/03/2016 11:00 pm
F22
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: rcoppola on 05/03/2016 11:00 pm
C-40
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Misha Vargas on 05/03/2016 11:02 pm
I-19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Blacktom on 05/03/2016 11:07 pm
I19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Blacktom on 05/03/2016 11:09 pm
I18

If previous is already taken I see.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: BigDustyman on 05/03/2016 11:18 pm
j20
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: alienmike on 05/03/2016 11:23 pm
K-17
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: SirKeplan on 05/03/2016 11:26 pm
I23 Please!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: subzero788 on 05/03/2016 11:37 pm
K15
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: deadman719 on 05/03/2016 11:40 pm
L-25, please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: scienceguy on 05/03/2016 11:45 pm
F-26 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Striker-tech on 05/03/2016 11:46 pm
I-25, if you please.

Long-time lurker, pretty sad first post.   ;)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: gth871r on 05/03/2016 11:55 pm
Q-19 For me
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DeanG1967 on 05/03/2016 11:58 pm
R-29 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: virnin on 05/04/2016 12:05 am
P20
Hopefully within the skid zone!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: burningsheep on 05/04/2016 12:07 am
n17
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Avron on 05/04/2016 12:09 am
S21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Darga on 05/04/2016 12:14 am
G-23
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: dmc6960 on 05/04/2016 12:27 am
H-20
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: kenny008 on 05/04/2016 12:27 am
K-16 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: hamerad on 05/04/2016 12:29 am
P19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: the_other_Doug on 05/04/2016 12:30 am
J-16 please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: pericynthion on 05/04/2016 12:31 am
L-16
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: llanitedave on 05/04/2016 12:32 am
H-15.  They're sure going fast!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: John Alan on 05/04/2016 12:34 am
J26
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: S.Paulissen on 05/04/2016 12:46 am
I24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: AndyX on 05/04/2016 01:00 am
H22
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Wolfram66 on 05/04/2016 01:15 am
K14 for me please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Wolfram66 on 05/04/2016 01:21 am
My Son David will like i29
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: HarbingerDawn on 05/04/2016 01:23 am
N-25
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: leetdan on 05/04/2016 01:27 am
P-22
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: toren on 05/04/2016 01:40 am
O24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: lark on 05/04/2016 01:49 am
M28
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DanielW on 05/04/2016 01:57 am
My Son David will like i29

I am not sure what the rules are on a post like this, but I know for a fact that the scraper does not know your son David. It only registers 1 vote per username.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: kona314 on 05/04/2016 01:57 am
G14
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Rifleman on 05/04/2016 02:08 am
P-27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Nilof on 05/04/2016 02:15 am
K25
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: blah on 05/04/2016 02:16 am
I-15
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: te_atl on 05/04/2016 02:20 am
H18
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Orbiter on 05/04/2016 02:25 am
G21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Zed_Noir on 05/04/2016 02:27 am
M26
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: OxCartMark on 05/04/2016 02:28 am
I'll be P-23 ya see?
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: BobHk on 05/04/2016 02:29 am
H15
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: meekGee on 05/04/2016 02:41 am
O16
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: dbg on 05/04/2016 02:42 am
I 17
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Seamus on 05/04/2016 02:43 am
J14
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mvpel on 05/04/2016 02:43 am
Q21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DigitalMan on 05/04/2016 03:00 am
M16
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: GeneBelcher on 05/04/2016 03:17 am
L29
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mdspacefan on 05/04/2016 03:19 am
J27 Please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: ChefPat on 05/04/2016 03:21 am
S15 please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: dvdt on 05/04/2016 03:30 am
L15
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: gt3499a on 05/04/2016 03:38 am
m27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: kadib on 05/04/2016 03:39 am
H23
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: TheSwiss on 05/04/2016 04:20 am
I-14
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mikelepage on 05/04/2016 04:45 am
I-29 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: sewebster on 05/04/2016 05:03 am
H16
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: EspenU on 05/04/2016 05:31 am
G19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Bynaus on 05/04/2016 05:47 am
M-25 for me!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mikes on 05/04/2016 06:01 am
Q20 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Draggendrop on 05/04/2016 06:05 am
Q-22 Please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mtakala24 on 05/04/2016 06:05 am
G27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: M G B on 05/04/2016 06:09 am
O 25 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: KimiNewt on 05/04/2016 06:32 am
F27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: WM68 on 05/04/2016 06:36 am
H31
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: WallyEU on 05/04/2016 06:40 am
Q17
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: LucR on 05/04/2016 06:44 am
Q18
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: vaporcobra on 05/04/2016 06:55 am
P24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: jnaO on 05/04/2016 06:58 am
Q-23 please (second try)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: jnaO on 05/04/2016 07:02 am
So, how does this work, I initially selected row p col 23 but it didn't count as a valid vote, anyone knows why? Is it because I edited the post (although not my selected spot, just removed an auto-added signature from an app I used to type the msg)?
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: darkenfast on 05/04/2016 07:05 am
L-26, please!  Thanks for the entertainment!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: sewebster on 05/04/2016 07:06 am
So, how does this work, I initially selected row p col 23 but it didn't count as a valid vote, anyone knows why? Is it because I edited the post (although not my selected spot, just removed an auto-added signature from an app I used to type the msg)?

Edited posts are not allowed for this, so that sounds like the problem (should be in the first post instructions).
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Nick L on 05/04/2016 07:09 am
R26
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: SimonShuttle on 05/04/2016 07:11 am
L26

Thanks!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: strax on 05/04/2016 07:33 am
G-18 please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: kamilfredo on 05/04/2016 08:02 am
M-11
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: pabell on 05/04/2016 08:10 am
H25

 ;D
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Mark McCombs on 05/04/2016 08:17 am
J15
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Bargemanos on 05/04/2016 09:11 am
L-27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Jarnis on 05/04/2016 09:20 am
G-25
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Joel on 05/04/2016 09:33 am
G26!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: TheSpaceRod on 05/04/2016 11:16 am
N-26
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: PerW on 05/04/2016 11:28 am
M14
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Ethelred the Unready on 05/04/2016 11:41 am
K-27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mike721 on 05/04/2016 12:02 pm
I26
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: aameise9 on 05/04/2016 12:09 pm
M32
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: bregallad on 05/04/2016 12:24 pm
N-15 Please!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: neoforce on 05/04/2016 12:27 pm
O26
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: pmenstrom on 05/04/2016 01:17 pm
F-20
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mattstep on 05/04/2016 01:33 pm
Q-24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mwfair on 05/04/2016 01:34 pm
F21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: apirie98 on 05/04/2016 01:36 pm
G-17 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mhlas7 on 05/04/2016 01:44 pm
R-22
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: mchoudoir on 05/04/2016 02:10 pm
G-16 Please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: racevedo88 on 05/04/2016 02:16 pm
h-27 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: 3Davideo on 05/04/2016 02:17 pm
Q12 tyvm
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: huntster on 05/04/2016 02:25 pm
W-40, just to be that guy. Sploosh! ;)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: StarGeezer on 05/04/2016 02:31 pm
O15 PLEEZ
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Chris Bergin on 05/04/2016 02:39 pm
Well you get at least another day of bingo now it's been delayed 24 hours. Current selection state of play:
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lar on 05/04/2016 03:07 pm
As a note using Dan's Doorway to review hopefuls and hapless is helpful   http://asds.dansdoorway.com/ then click on the 3 horizontal lines at left for a drop down menu and click on hopefuls/hapless ... The rules are incorrect but Dan knows and is working on it he tells me.

As of right now the following 8 users have tried to submit votes (the scraper saw it) but they were not accepted (edited posts? not first on a square, you can see by searching the id why)

8 Users Without a Successful Vote

    BigDustyman
    BobHk
    kirghizstan
    mshook
    rcoppola
    SimonShuttle
    sngc
    stope19

Putting mshook in the search box (or just clicking on their ID) shows us this

mshook does not have a valid vote.
Square   Reference Post   Result
K-16    05/03/2016 09:55 PM    Post Edited

(the reference post is clickable too and takes you here)

So if you're on the hapless list, consider seeing why...

All in all this tool is awesome!  Thanks so much for doing this DanielW
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Citabria on 05/04/2016 03:16 pm
N-12 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Becker67 on 05/04/2016 03:17 pm
S 16 Please although I reckon it's gonna nail the bulls eye this time :)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: llanitedave on 05/04/2016 03:43 pm
H15


That's mine, I tell ya!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: AC0T on 05/04/2016 03:51 pm
H-12 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: shm6666 on 05/04/2016 04:02 pm
D-19 please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: fthomassy on 05/04/2016 04:38 pm
F-18 please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Herbie on 05/04/2016 04:55 pm
I27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: watermod on 05/04/2016 05:06 pm
L13
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Jaskentner on 05/04/2016 05:09 pm
Q16
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: CraigLieb on 05/04/2016 05:23 pm
L14
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: RocketmanUS on 05/04/2016 05:25 pm
G 15
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Kansan52 on 05/04/2016 05:28 pm
S32
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: ABlair on 05/04/2016 05:30 pm
N-28
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: chrisking0997 on 05/04/2016 05:33 pm
O-27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: koshvv on 05/04/2016 05:43 pm
N-14
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Spaceade on 05/04/2016 05:49 pm
R20
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: guyw on 05/04/2016 06:15 pm
R-23
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Chris_Pi on 05/04/2016 06:44 pm
R-19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: GORDAP on 05/04/2016 07:02 pm
F16 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: genoka on 05/04/2016 07:34 pm
R-18!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: bolun on 05/04/2016 07:55 pm
G-13
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Halidon on 05/04/2016 08:14 pm
Q-13 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: inonepiece on 05/04/2016 08:16 pm
Q25
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: rocx on 05/04/2016 08:31 pm
P-26!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: ziceva on 05/04/2016 08:40 pm
R-24
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: tdrb6115 on 05/04/2016 08:47 pm
E-21

Sent from my D5803 using Tapatalk

Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: PDZiemer on 05/05/2016 01:04 am
R17
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Wolfram66 on 05/05/2016 01:24 am
Can I get i28 for my son? DTS94
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: jon.amos on 05/05/2016 01:26 am
S-20
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: 411rocket on 05/05/2016 03:05 am
H-14 please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Wonger on 05/05/2016 08:01 am
K13
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: smh on 05/05/2016 08:17 am
K-28
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: John Santos on 05/05/2016 08:28 am
J13
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: First Mate Rummey on 05/05/2016 08:34 am
R-25  :D
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: pivkacik on 05/05/2016 09:18 am
O-9
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Paul Smith on 05/05/2016 09:23 am
M13
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Davinator on 05/05/2016 09:25 am
P-14 please.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Martin FL on 05/05/2016 12:40 pm
Q-15
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Almurray1958 on 05/05/2016 12:42 pm
E-20
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: meadows.st on 05/05/2016 02:43 pm
S-18 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: CaptLego on 05/05/2016 02:49 pm
O-28 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Earendil on 05/05/2016 04:01 pm
O-13 please

Sent from my LG-H960 using Tapatalk

Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: SirTim42 on 05/05/2016 04:07 pm
L28 please!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: teetlebomb on 05/05/2016 04:15 pm
E-23
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: kenban on 05/05/2016 04:31 pm
E-14
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: roflplatypus on 05/05/2016 05:34 pm
T21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: wxmeddler on 05/05/2016 06:24 pm
T27
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: tinorex on 05/05/2016 06:56 pm
D16
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: madanra on 05/05/2016 07:15 pm
S19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: rickl on 05/05/2016 07:22 pm
K12
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Reflectiv on 05/05/2016 09:20 pm
Q-32 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: MrHollifield on 05/05/2016 10:34 pm
G12 for the win!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: IainMcClatchie on 05/06/2016 12:05 am
Q-27.  I really wonder about the viability of some of the D and T rows.  If the center engine is on those rows, are all four legs really on the ship?
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Galactic Penguin SST on 05/06/2016 02:12 am
J-34 please
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lar on 05/06/2016 02:19 am
Q-27.  I really wonder about the viability of some of the D and T rows.  If the center engine is on those rows, are all four legs really on the ship?
No. These were viable before the rule change (that the stage has to return upright to port) but not any more. IMHO anyway.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: nat.vincent on 05/06/2016 03:55 am
J-28
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: foltster on 05/06/2016 04:09 am
S-22
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: intrepidpursuit on 05/06/2016 04:13 am
E-19
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Chris Bergin on 05/06/2016 04:34 am
Remember, if and when there's a launch, we'll stop taking selections (not that there's any advantage in picking one's last minute square during launch ;) - "Oh! That ascent profile and staging looks like it'll be heading to...." ;D)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: catdlr on 05/06/2016 04:38 am
Remember, if and when there's a launch, we'll stop taking selections (not that there's any advantage in picking one's last minute square during launch ;) - "Oh! That ascent profile and staging looks like it'll be heading to...." ;D)

So it "launch Time" instead of "Post Time"   ;)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Robotbeat on 05/06/2016 04:54 am
I-13
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: jongoff on 05/06/2016 04:58 am
G25
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Dagger on 05/06/2016 05:09 am
D-20
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: macpacheco on 05/06/2016 05:32 am
Looks like a bulleye landing. Yeah Baby ! Go SpaceX !
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Nintendo Maniac 64 on 05/06/2016 05:35 am
For the heck of it, I'll quickly say N-32 just to see if it still counts. :P

It's clearly not going to win, but I'm doing science here!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Orbiter on 05/06/2016 05:35 am
Man, I can tell those center squares are going to be extra-popular during the next bingo.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Retired Downrange on 05/06/2016 05:43 am
Looks closest to the center of any previous landing:

ASDS landing Bingo past results (please check for errors or omissions)

ASDS bingo

2015
April
CRS 6
1st prize  E-28 picked by NSF user tinorex
2nd prize L-28 picked by NSF user measdows.st

2016
January
Jason-3    square H-20 picked by NSF user ScottMC

March
SES 9 hole spanning squares R-34 and R-35, which were unpicked

April
CRS 8      square H-23  picked by NSF user Blah
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Zed_Noir on 05/06/2016 05:44 am
The question is did Chris B pick the winning square.  :P

If he did. Obivous collusion between him & the SX CTO.  ;D
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: llanitedave on 05/06/2016 06:37 am
In the future the first person to pick will be the winner, because it will always be the center square.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lar on 05/06/2016 06:41 am
There actually is no center square, IMHO... there are two squares that straddle the center[1] and a few that are really close. For the record I'm pretty sure I won this one. :)

1 - L 20 and L 21
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Chris Bergin on 05/06/2016 06:46 am
The question is did Chris B pick the winning square.  :P

If he did. Obivous collusion between him & the SX CTO.  ;D

The good news is, if I did win, someone else wins! ;D

Regardless, when that webcam image updated to show the stage sat there, this was my reaction, Klopp style.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Meltro on 05/06/2016 06:51 am
In the future the first person to pick will be the winner, because it will always be the center square.

I think that's a little optimistic (pessimistic?). Winds out there are pretty nuts, and one burst just before touchdown can move the whole shebang several meters, which it can do nothing about at the very end. I imagine we'll continue to see a decent spread around the deck.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Nintendo Maniac 64 on 05/06/2016 07:21 am
There actually is no center square, IMHO... there are two squares that straddle the center[1] and a few that are really close.
One could improve on this idea by making the center be a corner shared between four different squares; in the current set up that would possibly require adding at least another row after W so as to shift the closest set of corners more towards the actual center.


EDIT: Hmm that's interesting, my "N32" that I requested after the actual landing was in fact counted according to http://asds.dansdoorway.com/

It might be wise to consider doing something so that this can't be taken advantage of - like if the booster lands in an area that wasn't a popular area for bingo-picking, someone could quickly jump onto the forum and request a bingo location based on where it looked like the booster landed via the livestream.

Personally I would think that the easiest way to prevent this kind of abuse would be to cut off or not count any bingo requests once right when liftoff occurs (at that point it's clearly not a scrub but also likely would be early enough before any possible RUD occured)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DatUser14 on 05/06/2016 01:03 pm
So when will judging take place,When OCISLY returns to port, and we get photos? Or can someone fax Elon to get the winning square?
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lar on 05/06/2016 01:58 pm
So when will judging take place,When OCISLY returns to port, and we get photos? Or can someone fax Elon to get the winning square?

Fax? That's so 1980s... Tweet him the link to asds.dansdoorway.com and ask which square won[1]

And I would love to see the grid shifted so there are 4 "center" squares but it may make determining the winner even more problematic....

1- Doesn't matter, I won. Just sayin'
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: sevenperforce on 05/06/2016 02:18 pm
So when will judging take place,When OCISLY returns to port, and we get photos? Or can someone fax Elon to get the winning square?

Fax? That's so 1980s... Tweet him the link to asds.dansdoorway.com and ask which square won[1]

And I would love to see the grid shifted so there are 4 "center" squares but it may make determining the winner even more problematic....

1- Doesn't matter, I won. Just sayin'
Yeah, pretty sure you won.

If you already have L2 access you should give your prize to someone deserving!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: meekGee on 05/06/2016 02:22 pm
So when will judging take place,When OCISLY returns to port, and we get photos? Or can someone fax Elon to get the winning square?

Fax? That's so 1980s... Tweet him the link to asds.dansdoorway.com and ask which square won[1]

And I would love to see the grid shifted so there are 4 "center" squares but it may make determining the winner even more problematic....

1- Doesn't matter, I won. Just sayin'
It would be easier if they just paint the grid on the deck.

Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Helodriver on 05/06/2016 02:32 pm
Judging a winner will be done once the ASDS reruns to port. The plethora pf photos from many angles and overhead will make figuring out if Lar is the winner easier. :)   Although, if this gets as routine as SpaceX seems intent on making it, after a few more tries no one is even going to bother going to the port to look. ;)

As far as realigning the board, if you notice, the center is not represented by one square currently its at an intersection and this was done intentionally. If they ever score a perfect bullseye, there will likely be 4 winners. As for this morning's landing, from the one view we have it looks to be just slightly "south" of dead center so far.

We will know for sure in a few days!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: CraigLieb on 05/06/2016 02:50 pm
..
It would be easier if they just paint the grid on the deck.

...And have a downward facing camera with self cleaning crystal lense, and a string that drops from the center engine after the fires go out.
SpaceX, please get on making that flight hardware change so we can have instant Bingo winners..
 ::)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: meekGee on 05/06/2016 02:53 pm
..
It would be easier if they just paint the grid on the deck.

...And have a downward facing camera with self cleaning crystal lense, and a string that drops from the center engine after the fires go out.
SpaceX, please get on making that flight hardware change so we can have instant Bingo winners..
 ::)
Now you're just being silly. A downward facing laser pointer would clearly be the better choice!

Ooh, and an automated scoreboard!

Who even needs a rocket?
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lee Jay on 05/06/2016 03:04 pm
Looks to me like M to N, 22 to 23, give or take a bit.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Chris Bergin on 05/06/2016 03:06 pm
Looks like K-20 to me....
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: WM68 on 05/06/2016 03:22 pm
After long and extremely complex calculations involving angles of attack and determining the sun angle during darkness i've come to the conclusion that my chosen spot H-31 is...... not even close!

And they were gonna grease the deck so it would slide to my spot!!

 ;D
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: cartman on 05/06/2016 03:41 pm
Can someone calculate how much water they would need to add to the forward tanks so that it slides to L-19? I'm asking for a friend  ;D
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: skyguy on 05/06/2016 03:44 pm
Looks to me like M to N, 22 to 23, give or take a bit.

Ooh, ooh, keep looking and maybe it will look like L-23.  So close!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Kansan52 on 05/06/2016 03:49 pm
After long and extremely complex calculations involving angles of attack and determining the sun angle during darkness i've come to the conclusion that my chosen spot H-31 is...... not even close!

And they were gonna grease the deck so it would slide to my spot!!

 ;D

Exhaust must have burned off the grease!  ;D
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: sevenperforce on 05/06/2016 04:02 pm
..
It would be easier if they just paint the grid on the deck.

...And have a downward facing camera with self cleaning crystal lense, and a string that drops from the center engine after the fires go out.
SpaceX, please get on making that flight hardware change so we can have instant Bingo winners..
 ::)
The obvious solution is to replace the metal deck with a series of pressure-sensitive tiles, each with its own independent wifi connection, so that touchdown will indicate the four tiles that the landing legs are resting on and will automatically find the tile directly between those four tiles, then automatically post the winning tile on the forum thread by the time the video feed shows a successful landing.

Later on we can have side bets for the axial angle at which the rocket touches down.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Jdeshetler on 05/06/2016 04:14 pm
Unofficial.

This is a pure guesswork for those who can't wait...

Cheers
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DatUser14 on 05/06/2016 04:35 pm
edit: made me sound greedy. Maybe rejigger the grid to have one square on the center of the X, to simplify this
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Retired Downrange on 05/06/2016 04:37 pm
Of course I am hoping that it landed on M22 (my choice) it is VERY close. 😎
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lar on 05/06/2016 04:47 pm
If you already have L2 access you should give your prize to someone deserving!
But of course. Whoever sucks up to me the best.. :)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: sevenperforce on 05/06/2016 05:00 pm
If you already have L2 access you should give your prize to someone deserving!
But of course. Whoever sucks up to me the best.. :)
Well, I won't be sucking up to you. You're clearly quite wise so you'll make the best decision on your own, no need for sucking up. Sucking up would, in fact, be pointless, for those reasons.

 ;D
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: IainMcClatchie on 05/06/2016 09:43 pm
Did anyone else notice the prolonged fire after engine shutdown after landing on the barge?  SpaceX took several seconds to get a remote-controlled water jet going, and then couldn't get the jet to hit the engine cluster due to crosswind, and then cut away from the barge.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0bMeDj76ig?t=29m43s (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0bMeDj76ig?t=29m43s)

I'd guess the kerosene distribution system had a small rupture on the way down.  If they didn't get that fire out, they may have a badly damaged rocket at this point.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: tleski on 05/06/2016 10:31 pm
Did anyone else notice the prolonged fire after engine shutdown after landing on the barge? 

We should add this question to the list of questions asked after each landing/test firing/launch abort.

We saw these fires several times. For example after Orbcomm-2 landing in December and after SES9 launch abort in February this year. They seem to be relatively harmless to the stage.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DatUser14 on 05/06/2016 11:14 pm
Asked musk on Twitter which square the stage landed on, linked scraper with image. Let's see if he responds.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Chris_Pi on 05/07/2016 05:32 am
Asked musk on Twitter which square the stage landed on, linked scraper with image. Let's see if he responds.

That's even better than having them paint the grid on.  8)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lar on 05/07/2016 05:36 am
Asked musk on Twitter which square the stage landed on, linked scraper with image. Let's see if he responds.

That's even better than having them paint the grid on.  8)
Well...

Musk might think he has the authoritative answer...  YOU might think he has the authoritative answer ...  but we KNOW who ACTUALLY does. Helodriver! :)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Helodriver on 05/07/2016 06:32 am
Asked musk on Twitter which square the stage landed on, linked scraper with image. Let's see if he responds.

That's even better than having them paint the grid on.  8)
Well...

Musk might think he has the authoritative answer...  YOU might think he has the authoritative answer ...  but we KNOW who ACTUALLY does. Helodriver! :)

Hey, no need to suck up to me, you've already got lifetime L2. :)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DatUser14 on 05/10/2016 01:41 pm
with the new 3 angle video, can triangulation be done to determine the winning square?
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: silverfire on 05/10/2016 08:34 pm
(http://i.imgur.com/uTNB3qL.jpg)

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinteresting/comments/4iqi6u/bonus_pic_my_brother_just_sent_me_of_the_spacex/

Still not absolutely clear which square it landed on, but I think it's at least a little clearer than what we've gotten so far.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: sevenperforce on 05/10/2016 09:02 pm
Even better shot from the same redditor.

Based on this, I'm calling L22 by a hair.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Helodriver on 05/10/2016 10:32 pm
So after watching the three view landing video multiple times, the arrival photos from last night, this mornings unloading, and once again some very helpful aerial shots and finally a private message from someone who has been aboard, the winning square has been determined.

In what is by far the most centered landing yet of any attempt, the winning square is L-22

Congratulations DanielW our very own scrapermaster for making the pick on page 3 of the comment section.

              "L-22 and the scraper is up. I never seem to be checking NSF when these things go up. Sorry." 


Great luck to the winner, and prizes to all the winners up to this point should be in the mail by the end of this week. :)


ASDS Bingo Will Return!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Chris Bergin on 05/10/2016 11:19 pm
Fix ;)

We need a second place as Dan is obviously already L2.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Retired Downrange on 05/10/2016 11:40 pm
Um... I picked M22 and I don't have L2
(Or perhaps Dan can gift his prize to someone he chooses)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Ohsin on 05/11/2016 12:30 am
Can it get any better than this? L2, L22 dead center on mission they weren't expecting to land successfully...

Congrats scrape master ;D
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: sevenperforce on 05/11/2016 12:48 am
Congrats Dan!

If there is a second place to give L2 to, I would say L21 is closer than anything.

If Dan chooses to give his L2 to someone else then obviously it should be me, for calling him the winner right before Helo did.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DanielW on 05/11/2016 01:27 am
Well this was unexpected but I finally have a forum avatar! Thanks for the great game Helo.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DarkenedOne on 05/11/2016 01:31 am
You know if you look closely at the video footage for the landing in the link below you can see that the booster moves over slightly after landing.  Maybe you guys should factor that in.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LHqLz9ni0Bo?t=42
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lar on 05/11/2016 03:23 am
Well this was unexpected but I finally have a forum avatar! Thanks for the great game Helo.
and what an avatar it is!
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: ClayJar on 05/11/2016 09:09 pm
In what is by far the most centered landing yet of any attempt, the winning square is L-22

In the immortal words of Maxwell Smart, "Missed it by that much."  ;D

I can't argue with our most excellent DanielW winning, but would it be agreeable to grant me official "Most Efficient Loser" status for not only being *sooooo* close on the very first pick, but also prophetically stating my method of failure?  8)

Okay, now that I got to hit the center, I suppose I'm committed to hoping for unexpectedly calm seas and winds on landing so I don't miss by a scoot.  ;D

Missed by a scoot, and yes, I can live with that.  ;)
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: DatUser14 on 05/11/2016 09:14 pm
So close, I think I was L-21.
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: ClayJar on 05/11/2016 09:35 pm
So close, I think I was L-21.
Oh, now don't steal my thunder [rumble of a passing moderately-laden bicycle], now.  You were *way* off at L-20.  ;D
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Csnyder65 on 08/10/2016 06:24 pm
I 25
Title: Re: SpaceX JCSAT Don't Go Splat Landing Bingo
Post by: Lar on 08/10/2016 07:22 pm
I 25

Wrong thread. I'll send a PM but the current thread is the "gotta catch em all" thread.

http://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=40894