Author Topic: Early European spaceflight history, manned and unmanned, about 1950-1975  (Read 70576 times)

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
Two pictures, stage 2 of 3 "Coralie" of Europa rocket F15 (about 1971) at Flugwerft Schleissheim, Deutsches Museum, Munich, front and back.

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
Two pictures, stage 3 of 3 "Astris" of Europa rocket F15 (about 1971) at Flugwerft Schleissheim, Deutsches Museum, Munich, front and back.

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
Transporteur Aérospatial / Aerospace Transporter were a bunch of RLV / TSTO studies done in the mid-1960's by Eurospace, which still exists and is a lose association of big european aerospace companies.

That peculiar Hermes- look-alike orbiter was to be attached to a Centaur -like hydrolox stage, the whole stack dropped at Mach 6 by a "super Concorde", to be built by Dassault.

VERA was something else entirely. It was very much France own ASSET and while it did not flew a ground model was thermal tested. Test flights would have used a Diamant first stage, that is a L17 - 17 tons of liquid propellants - Emeraude or Améthyste.

VERAS article. https://web.archive.org/web/20130508142014/https://www.anciensonera.fr/sites/default/files/fichiers%20pdf/Bulletin_AAO_Hors-Serie-Espace.pdf
In order to avoid going off-topic in the Hermes thread, please let me make a few notes here.

While there was European interest in these X-20 Dyna-Soar-like spaceplanes, I have not seen VERAS mentioned in EUROSPACE proceedings from 1963 to about 1966. Those are the first to fourth proceedings. What is studied are generic spaceplanes to be developed which of course links to Eugen Sänger and his life-long interest in these spaceplanes. In German they were called "Raumflugtransporter" or "Raumtransporter" and in English "AeroSpace Transporter" or "Space Transporter and Associated Projects". Not sure about the French names for these projects.

Note that Eugen Sänger in about 1963 was in a leading position at Eurospace, including subgroup Spaceplane, which presumably relates to their study of spaceplanes. So far, the impression is that after his death in 1964 the spaceplane discussion at Eurospace also stops. The Eurospace reports/memoranda titled "Aerospace Transporter" from October 1964 and "Memorandum: A proposal for a Feasibility Study of an Aerospace Transporter System", March 1965, are reports that I could not locate and read so far.

While I read about some German spaceplane projects like the RT-8 /Saenger 1, I see few mentions of French interest or names of similar projects. VERAS is such a project though. Was VERAS known in English or German under a different name? Were the French more interested in a local French spaceplane project instead of a European one?

In any case, I will have to prioritize reading the book "French Secret Projects 3: French and European Spaceplane Designs 1964-1994" which is described as
Quote
In 1963, Eugen Sänger, became head of the Eurospace organisation which promoted the 'AeroSpace Transporter'. In response to a Eurospace call, aircraft makers in France, Germany and UK designed recoverable, winged spacecraft. From 1964 to 1970 the French government led studies to evaluate the feasibility of the concept.
Those studies, under the leadership of the French Centre National d'Etudes Spatiales (CNES), coalesced into the Hermes spaceplane which was then adopted by the European Space Agency. In parallel, Germany and UK proposed fully recoverable designs while other countries, including Japan, India and Russia came to CNES to share ideas about spaceplane design. Unfortunately Hermes was never launched and by 1994 was abandoned after many alternative propositions were discussed.

This book relates the story of these remarkable concepts, crossovers between aircraft and spacecraft beginning with the 'antipodal bomber' of 1944 and continuing to Aerospatiale STS-2000 project through the Transporteur Aero-Spatial, VERAS, AW Pyramid, Bumerang, Sänger II, HOTOL, Hermes, and Taranis. Non-European projects like Dyna-Soar, Hyperplane, HOPE, and MAKS are also be covered. It provides a fascinating and detailed account of these projects which, being half-way between aircraft and spacecraft, have hitherto often been therefore often neglected by aviation writers and historians
Other leads to French projects and Eurospace memoranda are most welcome of course.

Offline Apollo22

  • Full Member
  • *
  • Posts: 128
  • Liked: 86
  • Likes Given: 597
Hi,
We called it "Transporteur Aérospatial". And VERAS was something else entirely - unrelated.

Best way to put it
Transporteur Aérospatial = Aerospaceplane
VERAS = ASSET ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASSET_(spacecraft) )

Aerospaceplane =/= DynaSoar =/= ASSET.  Same story for Transporteur Aérospatial and VERAS.

Nord Aviation (public company, later fused with Sud aviation in to SNIAS, then Aérospatiale) did VERAS but earlier on, they also had Transporteur Aérospatial studies.

https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/threads/various-dassault-jet-projects-and-prototypes.15791/
https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/threads/french-tsto-studies-of-the-60s.4096/
https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/threads/french-secret-projects-3.29611/page-2

Quote
While there was European interest in these X-20 Dyna-Soar-like spaceplanes, I have not seen VERAS mentioned in EUROSPACE proceedings from 1963 to about 1966.

It's because
1-Eurospace was a loose association of European aerospace companies
2-VERAS was 100% french
3-And funded mostly by the military, hence it produced very few public papers. 
4-I think it also came after 1966, but I have to check the dates.

Cross-posting VERAS from the other thread.
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=16621.msg2697955#msg2697955
« Last Edit: 07/13/2025 03:09 pm by Apollo22 »

Offline Apollo22

  • Full Member
  • *
  • Posts: 128
  • Liked: 86
  • Likes Given: 597
My research on VERAS brought a few bits, see attached.

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
Hi,
We called it "Transporteur Aérospatial".
Thanks, that is helpful for further research. While I am fluent in English and German, I struggle through the French. Welcome to Europe.

And VERAS was something else entirely - unrelated.

Best way to put it
Transporteur Aérospatial = Aerospaceplane
VERAS = ASSET ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ASSET_(spacecraft) )

Aerospaceplane =/= DynaSoar =/= ASSET.  Same story for Transporteur Aérospatial and VERAS.
Thanks, noted.

Nord Aviation (public company, later fused with Sud aviation in to SNIAS, then Aérospatiale) did VERAS but earlier on, they also had Transporteur Aérospatial studies.
Yes, I can see the company names Nord Aviation and Sud aviation as members in the Eurospace 1963 proceedings, attached..

https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/threads/various-dassault-jet-projects-and-prototypes.15791/
https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/threads/french-tsto-studies-of-the-60s.4096/
https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/threads/french-secret-projects-3.29611/page-2
Will have a read :)

Quote
While there was European interest in these X-20 Dyna-Soar-like spaceplanes, I have not seen VERAS mentioned in EUROSPACE proceedings from 1963 to about 1966.

It's because
1-Eurospace was a loose association of European aerospace companies
2-VERAS was 100% french
3-And funded mostly by the military, hence it produced very few public papers. 
4-I think it also came after 1966, but I have to check the dates.
Makes sense.

Offline Apollo22

  • Full Member
  • *
  • Posts: 128
  • Liked: 86
  • Likes Given: 597
Be my guest. Btw, you should really join this forum, it's an amazing place. https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/   

Your extensive space research will probably be much appreciated there too.
« Last Edit: 07/13/2025 06:14 pm by Apollo22 »

Offline Blackstar

  • Veteran
  • Senior Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 17984
  • Liked: 10821
  • Likes Given: 2
Be my guest. Btw, you should really join this forum, it's an amazing place. https://www.secretprojects.co.uk/   

Your extensive space research will probably be much appreciated there too.

I'm on there and it's not very good for space topics. It's mostly a waste of time.

Offline Apollo22

  • Full Member
  • *
  • Posts: 128
  • Liked: 86
  • Likes Given: 597
I have to partly agree, but that's because Statler an Waldorf keep arguing and arguing again.  ;D 

Offline Blackstar

  • Veteran
  • Senior Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 17984
  • Liked: 10821
  • Likes Given: 2
I have to partly agree, but that's because Statler an Waldorf keep arguing and arguing again.  ;D 

It's partly the focus--the site is dedicated to discuss things that did not happen, not things that did. Yeah, occasionally they cover stuff that did happen, but it's already pretty limited.

And a number of the participants on the space sub-group don't have a substantial knowledge base.

The site can be interesting, but it's a bit thin on space.

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
Transporteur Aérospatial / Aerospace Transporter were a bunch of RLV / TSTO studies done in the mid-1960's by Eurospace, which still exists and is a lose association of big european aerospace companies.

That peculiar Hermes- look-alike orbiter was to be attached to a Centaur -like hydrolox stage, the whole stack dropped at Mach 6 by a "super Concorde", to be built by Dassault.

VERA was something else entirely. It was very much France own ASSET and while it did not flew a ground model was thermal tested. Test flights would have used a Diamant first stage, that is a L17 - 17 tons of liquid propellants - Emeraude or Améthyste.

VERAS article. https://web.archive.org/web/20130508142014/https://www.anciensonera.fr/sites/default/files/fichiers%20pdf/Bulletin_AAO_Hors-Serie-Espace.pdf
Note that Eugen Sänger in about 1963 was in a leading position at Eurospace, including subgroup Spaceplane, which presumably relates to their study of spaceplanes. So far, the impression is that after his death in 1964 the spaceplane discussion at Eurospace also stops. The Eurospace reports/memoranda titled "Aerospace Transporter" from October 1964 and "Memorandum: A proposal for a Feasibility Study of an Aerospace Transporter System", March 1965, are reports that I could not locate and read so far.
Some progress. I have a copy now of the Eurospace reports/memoranda titled "Aerospace Transporter" from October 1964 but am still chasing the second document the "Memorandum: A proposal for a Feasibility Study of an Aerospace Transporter System", March 1965
Quote
In any case, I will have to prioritize reading the book "French Secret Projects 3: French and European Spaceplane Designs 1964-1994"
And I have the book at home and am reading. Lots of details and context. Cool!
« Last Edit: 08/03/2025 05:59 pm by leovinus »

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
Transporteur Aérospatial / Aerospace Transporter were a bunch of RLV / TSTO studies done in the mid-1960's by Eurospace, which still exists and is a lose association of big european aerospace companies.

That peculiar Hermes- look-alike orbiter was to be attached to a Centaur -like hydrolox stage, the whole stack dropped at Mach 6 by a "super Concorde", to be built by Dassault.

VERA was something else entirely. It was very much France own ASSET and while it did not flew a ground model was thermal tested. Test flights would have used a Diamant first stage, that is a L17 - 17 tons of liquid propellants - Emeraude or Améthyste.

VERAS article. https://web.archive.org/web/20130508142014/https://www.anciensonera.fr/sites/default/files/fichiers%20pdf/Bulletin_AAO_Hors-Serie-Espace.pdf
Note that Eugen Sänger in about 1963 was in a leading position at Eurospace, including subgroup Spaceplane, which presumably relates to their study of spaceplanes. So far, the impression is that after his death in 1964 the spaceplane discussion at Eurospace also stops. The Eurospace reports/memoranda titled "Aerospace Transporter" from October 1964 and "Memorandum: A proposal for a Feasibility Study of an Aerospace Transporter System", March 1965, are reports that I could not locate and read so far.
Some progress. I have a copy now of the Eurospace reports/memoranda titled "Aerospace Transporter" from October 1964 but am still chasing the second document the "Memorandum: A proposal for a Feasibility Study of an Aerospace Transporter System", March 1965
The report "Memorandum: A proposal for a Feasibility Study of an Aerospace Transporter System, March 1965" which was eluding me has also been found, yeah. The findings and the story have been summarized in a two part article that should appear soon. 

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
I wrote up some thoughts after sleuthing through the European archives. This is part one. Happy reading.
EUROSPACE and the European spaceplane (part 1)
https://www.thespacereview.com/article/5084/1
Quote
In 1964, when Frank Sinatra sang “Fly Me to the Moon,” he was not entirely sure whether he wanted to ride a rocket or a spaceplane but it was clear was that he counted on a first-class ticket. The dream to fly into space on an airplane is old. In the last 100 years, the most well-known concepts include Eugen Sänger’s 1933 “Amerika-Bomber” and later “Silbervogel” followed by many similar concepts from the 1950s and later. [17, 34]
« Last Edit: 10/21/2025 06:11 pm by leovinus »

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
In the course of research into European spaceflight history, I found that whole sets conference proceedings are very difficult to track down. In particular, I am still chasing the "European Spaceflight Symposium" proceedings, list below. Titles such as "Europäischer Raumfahrtkongress" in German or "European Space flight Symposium" in English and not to be confused with the "International Spaceflight Symposium" or "International Astronautical Congress (IAC)".

While individual article are sometimes reprinted, particular English articles in JBIS or BIS Spaceflight, please note that in the early years these conferences were held in three languages plus translators. These articles are in any of French, English and German languages. While I could find pretty complete lists of individual conference papers and authors, the full proceedings elude me. Any pointers or copies would be appreciated. Am happy to share the detailed lists of papers but I do not want to add too much noise here :)

- 1st "European Spaceflight Symposium", London, June 26-28, 1961.
- 2nd European Symposium of Space Technology, Paris, 18-20 June 1962.
- "Third European Space flight Symposium, Stuttgart, Germany 21-24 MAY 1963. (Possibly https://d-nb.info/gnd/16056756-7 )
- IV. Europäischen Raumfahrtkongreß in Rom vom 19.-21.6.1964.
- Fifth European Spaceflight Symposium, München, Germany, July 19-22 1965.
- "Sixth european symposium on space technology", Brighton, UK, 23-25 May, 1966,
- 7th European Space Flight Congress, Bordeaux, France, May 22-24,1967
- 8th San Giorgio, Venice, Italy, 27-29 MAY 1968. ( Possibly AED-CONF.68-082. (4091))
- 9th European Space Symposium, London, 14 - 16 May 1969.

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
I wrote up some thoughts after sleuthing through the European archives. This is part one. Happy reading.
EUROSPACE and the European spaceplane (part 1)
https://www.thespacereview.com/article/5084/1
Quote
In 1964, when Frank Sinatra sang “Fly Me to the Moon,” he was not entirely sure whether he wanted to ride a rocket or a spaceplane but it was clear was that he counted on a first-class ticket. The dream to fly into space on an airplane is old. In the last 100 years, the most well-known concepts include Eugen Sänger’s 1933 “Amerika-Bomber” and later “Silbervogel” followed by many similar concepts from the 1950s and later. [17, 34]
EUROSPACE and the European spaceplane (part 2)
https://www.thespacereview.com/article/5088/1

This is more on the technical concepts from various countries and companies. In the past, I read about some of these but wondered how it all fit together. The article clarifies the relations and designs. I am still working on more materials and there might be a follow-up in future.

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
The news of OHB Establishes the European Spaceport Company included a note
Quote
The company’s involvement in launch infrastructure development in French Guiana also extends to the new multi-user commercial ELM facility being built on the grounds of the former Diamant launch pad
I did not realize that the "Diamant" pad was still around. Kind of begs the question what other, old facilities are still in French Guiana.
« Last Edit: 11/13/2025 01:31 pm by leovinus »

Offline Blackhorse

  • Member
  • Posts: 29
  • Liked: 24
  • Likes Given: 205
The news of OHB Establishes the European Spaceport Company included a note
Quote
The company’s involvement in launch infrastructure development in French Guiana also extends to the new multi-user commercial ELM facility being built on the grounds of the former Diamant launch pad
I did not realize that the "Diamant" pad was still around. Kind of begs the question what other, old facilities are still in French Guiana.

The old Diamant pad was a little appart from the Europa / Ariane area. Itself a larger distance from the peculiar Soyuz launch complex (the Soyuz flame trench had to be carved out of a granite bedrock : tedious job !). https://spaceflightnow.com/2015/03/24/photos-soyuz-rocket-transferred-to-jungle-launch-pad

Kourou hasn't as many rocket pads as The Cape, but still it's a burgeonning space coast.

Diamant launch area stopped being used after September 1975 and the last Diamant launch. France canned Diamant to fund L3S, better known as Ariane 1. CNES budget was being curtailed at a time when France got Ariane running in 73' by paying 60% of the development costs.

Some pictures taken in 2000.
http://www.capcomespace.net/dossiers/espace_europeen/CSG/ELD/ELD.htm

It stood abandonned for 40 years, 1976 - 2016.

Europa only launched from Kourou once, on November 5, 1971. Flight F11 was a miserable failure, due to incompatible stages and improper static electricity management inside the fairing and upper stages, that eventually killed the guidance system (adapted from the Jaguar fighter-bomber !)

18 months later in April 1973 Europa F12 Blue Streak had just reached Kourou when the program was definitively canned. That peculiar Blue Streak ended, somewhat, like the N-1s at Baikonur : scrapped in place, bits of rockets reused by locals. This is how a chicken coop somewhere in Kourou got a rocket roof !  8)

Europa launch complex was entirely rebuilt as Ariane ELA-1, first used on Christmas eve 1979. By the early 2000s it got rebuilt again, this time for VEGA, first flown in 2012.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ELA-1

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guiana_Space_Centre#ELA-2

Nothing gets lost !  ELA-2 of Ariane 4 has been partially demolished;  ELA-3 that launched Ariane 5 will launch VEGA-E. As for Ariane 6, it got a brand new ELA-4.
« Last Edit: 11/13/2025 03:12 pm by Blackhorse »

Offline Blackhorse

  • Member
  • Posts: 29
  • Liked: 24
  • Likes Given: 205
I should have known : Wikipedia has a map of Kourou. Of course it has ! 



The pads presently not in use are the Soyuz complex and ELA-2 from the late Ariane 4. You can bet they will be reused someday, as was the Diamant area.
« Last Edit: 11/13/2025 03:09 pm by Blackhorse »

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
The news of OHB Establishes the European Spaceport Company included a note
Quote
The company’s involvement in launch infrastructure development in French Guiana also extends to the new multi-user commercial ELM facility being built on the grounds of the former Diamant launch pad
I did not realize that the "Diamant" pad was still around. Kind of begs the question what other, old facilities are still in French Guiana.

The old Diamant pad was a little appart from the Europa / Ariane area. Itself a larger distance from the peculiar Soyuz launch complex (the Soyuz flame trench was carved into granite : tedious job !).

Kourou hasn't as many rocket pads as The Cape, but still it's a burgeonning space coast.

Diamant launch area stopped being used after September 1975 and the last Diamant launch. France canned Diamant to fund L3S, better known as Ariane 1. CNES budget was being curtailed at a time when France got Ariane running in 73' by paying 60% of the development costs.

Some pictures taken in 2000.
http://www.capcomespace.net/dossiers/espace_europeen/CSG/ELD/ELD.htm

It stood abandonned for 40 years, 1976 - 2016.
Thanks for that, and for the very detailed link with "Diamant" info. Great reading material. It always strikes me that so many stories are still untold. The ELDO SP-1006 index has at least a dozen references to technical reports with Diamant but all of those are non-public as far as I can see.

In the context of other interests such as the Aerospace Transporter, I could also ask whether the Kourou airport landing strip would actually be long enough to launch and land a Sänger/Mistral type plane?

Offline leovinus

  • Full Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 1500
  • Porto, Portugal
  • Liked: 1168
  • Likes Given: 2260
For Diamant, this would nice to read as well. Any leads?

- 2nd European Symposium of Space Technology, Paris, 18-20 June 1962
N62-15024
LE LANCEUR DE SATELLITE "DIAMANT". (THE SATELLITE LAUNCHER "DIAMANT").
M.R. Chevalier. Paris, Société française d'astronautique (1962).
« Last Edit: 11/13/2025 03:51 pm by leovinus »

Tags:
 

Advertisement NovaTech
Advertisement
Advertisement Margaritaville Beach Resort South Padre Island
Advertisement Brady Kenniston
Advertisement NextSpaceflight
Advertisement Nathan Barker Photography
1