Total Members Voted: 55
Voting closed: 06/30/2022 11:17 pm
Please define "debut" in this context, and please add an "after 2024" option.For "debut" do you mean a launch to LEO that meets all of its mission objectives?
The first pair of BE-4s for Vulcan have been regular news items for a very long time. I tried looking for evidence of a second pair. All I found was a post about the increase in staff at the factory in late June (the post - not sure when the increase in staff was spotted). BE-4 was not designed as an "easy" engine to build like Raptor. Even Raptor needed a huge tantrum from Elon and lots of real work to get into regular production.BE-4s are going to be eaten by Vulcans as fast as they are manufactured until production really ramps up. Jeff will have to choose between Vulcan/Kuiper launches and New Glenn. I fully expect to see "Where are my engines, Jeff?" replaced by something like "Now I know how you felt Tory".Has any evidence of BE-4 production rate escaped from Blue Origin's outstanding curtain of secrecy? I doubt we will see a very public Elon style hissy fit from Jeff but I am not expecting New Glenn to fly until months after Jeff makes a furious secret phone call about a shortage of engines.
Assuming the first launch is an expendable launch to orbit, I expect Q3 2024 at the earliest. Let's see if Blue can beat my expectations, which are already more rosy than their track record.
Quote from: high road on 06/22/2022 11:57 amAssuming the first launch is an expendable launch to orbit, I expect Q3 2024 at the earliest. Let's see if Blue can beat my expectations, which are already more rosy than their track record.Blue Origin said a few months ago that the New Glenn will fly next year. That prospect largely hinges upon Blue Origin beginning to manufacture production BE-3 engines to be used to power the New Glenn. Alternately, if a spent first or second stage of a Chinese space rocket washed up near the shore of the city where Blue Origin is headquartered, the Blue Origin would reverse-engineer the rocket propulsion system of that rocket stage to create an alternative engine with ultra-high specific impulse that combines the strengths of the BE-3 with the strengths of the BE-4.
Quote from: Vahe231991 on 07/06/2022 03:31 pmQuote from: high road on 06/22/2022 11:57 amAssuming the first launch is an expendable launch to orbit, I expect Q3 2024 at the earliest. Let's see if Blue can beat my expectations, which are already more rosy than their track record.Blue Origin said a few months ago that the New Glenn will fly next year. That prospect largely hinges upon Blue Origin beginning to manufacture production BE-3 engines to be used to power the New Glenn. Alternately, if a spent first or second stage of a Chinese space rocket washed up near the shore of the city where Blue Origin is headquartered, the Blue Origin would reverse-engineer the rocket propulsion system of that rocket stage to create an alternative engine with ultra-high specific impulse that combines the strengths of the BE-3 with the strengths of the BE-4.Given Blue's track record, if they announce their first flight within a few months, it will be years. See NS' first crewed flight. And their project that looks the most like they're reverse engineering a competitor's technology, has also been taking years by now.
Quote from: high road on 07/07/2022 06:27 amQuote from: Vahe231991 on 07/06/2022 03:31 pmQuote from: high road on 06/22/2022 11:57 amAssuming the first launch is an expendable launch to orbit, I expect Q3 2024 at the earliest. Let's see if Blue can beat my expectations, which are already more rosy than their track record.Blue Origin said a few months ago that the New Glenn will fly next year. That prospect largely hinges upon Blue Origin beginning to manufacture production BE-3 engines to be used to power the New Glenn. Alternately, if a spent first or second stage of a Chinese space rocket washed up near the shore of the city where Blue Origin is headquartered, the Blue Origin would reverse-engineer the rocket propulsion system of that rocket stage to create an alternative engine with ultra-high specific impulse that combines the strengths of the BE-3 with the strengths of the BE-4.Given Blue's track record, if they announce their first flight within a few months, it will be years. See NS' first crewed flight. And their project that looks the most like they're reverse engineering a competitor's technology, has also been taking years by now.It's worth remembering that Blue Origin deliberately DID NOT announce a date for a crewed New Shepard flight for years, because they knew there'd be delays no matter what announcement they made. Of course, they got flak for that tactic, too. And nobody expected BE-4 to be in development hell for so long.